Comparison time - which is which

[PiroStitch]

From a discussion a few weeks ago, I decided to take a few shots using both digital and film. Granted it's not the most scientific or the most accurate since all images have been resized and compressed a lot from the original.

Below are a few photos for comparison. Pretty sure I've stripped the EXIF data from each image so no cheating

The film I used was Kodak 400 Tri-X and all conversions were made to mimic Tri-X.















Thoughts?

[biggerry]

a bit unfair since your digital stuff probably emulates film stuff pretty closely.

film
digital
film
digital
digital
film
digital

[Reschsmooth]

film
digital
digital
digital
film
film
film

[Matt. K]

It's pretty tough to call from such small examples but my guess would be:
D
F
F
D
F
D
F

[chrisk]

I would be guessing so there's no point me answering really. the only one I would say I'd be relatively confident on is that #2 would be digital. I'd be more interested in some test shots of the same subjects in the same conditions.

[PiroStitch]

Sorry haven't had the time to do much over the past week or so.

Only number 5 and 6 were film, the rest were digital.

As requested, the following are from the same camera, subject and conditions but different mediums and formats (6x6 vs 645).

[zafra52]

I think you are proving the point loud
and clear. A good photograph is a good
photograph irrespective of the media.
Where the difference may become more
obvious is comparing the prints.